Is Al-Anon Really for Men? A conversation – 437

In the latest episode of The Recovery Show, host Spencer and guest Patrick B delve into the question, “Is Al-Anon really for men?” Both men are Al-Anon members, yet they wonder why the program largely features a predominantly female membership. The episode was recorded aboard a cruise ship following the AA International Convention, where Spencer and Patrick had a candid conversation about their experiences and observations.

Understanding Men's Involvement in Al-Anon

Patrick opens the discussion by expressing his curiosity about why only about 15% of Al-Anon members are men, despite men being equally affected by alcoholism, either as family members or friends of alcoholics. Through personal anecdotes, Patrick and Spencer highlight their encounters with male participation in Al-Anon meetings. They share that despite the visible male attendance at some meetings, women continue to constitute the majority. 

Spencer recalls attending meetings where the presence of men contributed to a healthy group dynamic. Patrick observed that meetings with a higher percentage of men often provide enriching sessions filled with experience, strength, and hope. Yet, he also notes that entering a predominantly female setting can make men feel uncomfortable due to stereotypes and traditional gender roles.

Challenges and Cultural Norms

The pair examines societal expectations, where men have historically been taught to be strong, self-reliant, and the primary problem-solvers—a notion that can deter men from joining groups like Al-Anon where sharing feelings is encouraged. Patrick reflects on his own hesitance to join until he reached a point of desperation. Spencer, too, shares his struggles in breaking away from societal norms of masculinity to embrace the supportive environment offered by Al-Anon.

Exploring Solutions and Acceptance

To address the imbalance, Spencer and Patrick consider how Al-Anon meetings can be more welcoming to men. They question if the structure or content within the program might unintentionally cater more to women, thus alienating male members. They discuss the existence of male-focused literature within Al-Anon, citing the men's newcomer packet (K-23), which includes brochures that address men's unique challenges.

Patrick, reflecting on his recent experiences with meetings, has found Adult Children of Alcoholics (ACA) gatherings more balanced in gender representation. This observation provokes further consideration into how different recovery programs might naturally attract diverse demographics.

Conclusion

Spencer and Patrick conclude by emphasizing Al-Anon’s valuable impact on their lives and encouraging other men to genuinely explore what the program can offer. Spencer advocates for meetings to maintain resources like the men's newcomer packet and to foster an environment that is welcoming to all. Both men echo the sentiment not to leave before witnessing the personal miracles recovery can bring.

Links

Patrick had a copy of the Men's Newcomer Packet from Al-Anon. We spent a little time looking through it.

The 2024 Al-Anon Membership Survey results are also available on the al-anon.org website.

Upcoming topics

Coming are episodes on Steps 11 and 12. Please email feedback@therecovery.show or call and leave a voicemail at 734-707-8795, with your questions or experience, strength and hope. Or just leave a comment right here.

Transcript

2 comments on “Is Al-Anon Really for Men? A conversation – 437

  1. PL says:

    Having gender specific spaces for recovery can be very important. But this conversation is very disturbing and rifled with sexism. If you wonder why men don’t seek the recovery of Alanon, looking inward at your own opinions and attitudes about others, especially women, may be enlightening about how other men may also view recovery in relationship and codependency. Women and girls and other types of men have existed with male dominated bias since the dawn of written language, and have had to adjust and adapt learning to their own, sometimes vey different opinions and view. Yet we still learn from literature (Moby Dick, all of Dickens) and religion ( the Bible, to start); from professional training Ied by and created for men; and male centric business and science. We learn from centuries of male led and dominated leadership and education.

    The men who adapt to Alanon as you see it may gain more because they have opened their own perspective and listening. Deeper issues surrounding men outside of the program rooted in a sexist view of themselves and others may exist that do not support their Alanon journey.

    Thank you for reading, and for bringing recovery to podcast.

  2. Catherine says:

    Thanks for an interesting topic. I (53f) have been pondering this for a while. I think both of you seem unique in your willingness to stay with your alcoholic wives. In my Al anon group there were 4 men (so a little under 50%); one father, two ex-husbands and one who doesn’t ‘need’ Al anon anymore because he’s getting divorced. In my life outside Al anon here in the UK, I don’t know any husband who stayed with and supported their alcoholic wife. Her behaviour was seen as unreasonable enough to divorce. Then he ‘no longer’ has a problem. Whereas, in contrast, all of the women (mostly over 60 except my daughter and me) stuck around for their husbands to sober up. I don’t know whether that makes me loyal or stupid. I’m still waiting for my husband to become a sober alcoholic, though he’s made huge steps, hopefully as a result of me stopping nagging, shaming and enabling him. One thing is for sure, Al Anon has changed my life and I appreciate all in my group; men and women.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.